Guidelines for Reproductive Rights
While current laws vary tremendously across States, this is what reproductive rights law should protect throughout the USA.
1. Use reliable contraception to prevent unwanted pregnancy during recreational sex (and practice safer sex). There's an old idiom that says "an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure." It is far easier and more practical to spend a little bit of energy toward preventing the crisis of an unwanted pregnancy than it is to spend enormous amounts of energy repeatedly solving an expensive and highly preventable situation.
2. Through the end of the 22nd week of gestation, you have the option to keep or abort your pregnancy. Before 23 weeks gestation, there is no person in your uterus, therefore, your right to liberty and self-determination permits access to abortion care. Consider carefully; do not make this decision lightly, and do not take your fertility for granted. Continuing a pregnancy is a decision best made when you desire to become a mother and believe you are prepared to provide a child with a safe, stable, and loving home. Not every woman is in that position. Women choose abortion for many reasons, including rape, incest, fetal anomalies, contraceptive failure, teen or child pregnancy, financial hardship, health concerns, and relationship instability. If abortion is your choice, then the earlier you abort, the better, for several reasons: (a) earlier abortions typically cost less money than later abortions, (b) pregnancy places stress on your body that intensifies as the pregnancy progresses, and (c) earlier abortion experiences are significantly less painful than later procedures or giving birth.
3. From the beginning of the 23rd week of gestation through the end of pregnancy, there are three situations in which ending a pregnancy may become necessary. Ending a pregnancy at this stage doesn't necessarily mean an abortion; early delivery is often appropriate. Later abortions are very rare and serious occurrences. According to the CDC, over three-fourths (77.7%) of abortions are performed before the 10th-week gestation; over nine-tenths (92.2%) of abortions are performed before the second trimester (i.e., before the 14th-week gestation); and nearly all (more than 99%) are performed before the 23rd-week gestation. The three situations that may necessitate ending a pregnancy are:
-
Mother’s health crisis: Serious medical conditions or pregnancy complications that threaten the mother's life or pose a substantial risk of physical or psychiatric harm, including but not limited to heart disease, kidney or liver failure, cancer, stroke, blood clots, severe depression with suicidal ideation, preeclampsia, eclampsia, HELLP syndrome, placental complications, sepsis, etc. ➜ Early delivery is preferred when it offers a medically reasonable opportunity to preserve the baby's life and health without increasing serious risk to the mother. Abortion remains an option to safeguard the mother's life or health. For the full description of this exception, see “Pregnant Person’s Health Crisis Abortion Exception Beginning at 23 Weeks of Gestation” at the bottom of this page.
-
Baby’s health crisis: misdeveloped or missing vital organs (kidneys, heart, lungs, brain*, etc.), vital organ failure, inoperable tumors, etc. ➜ Preference for appropriate medical, palliative, and/or hospice care, and, if needed, early delivery. However, the pregnant patient's informed preferences should be respected, and abortion remains an option when a severe fetal condition makes ending the pregnancy a consideration. For the full explanation, see “Baby’s Health Crisis Abortion Exception Beginning at 23 Weeks of Gestation” at the bottom of this page.
-
Barriers to abortion access before 23 weeks: financial hardship, lack of childcare, human trafficking, abusive living situation, etc. ➜ No person should be forced to endure an unwanted pregnancy. We should strengthen social programs that help prevent these circumstances and support people experiencing them. Available options include maternal support services, adoption services, and early delivery, but not abortion. Forcing someone to provide bodily support against their will is morally untenable and, given the work of pregnancy, inconsistent with the Thirteenth Amendment's prohibition of involuntary servitude. However, early delivery carries risks for a prematurely born baby, and current medical technology cannot eliminate all adverse outcomes. A pregnant person in this situation must weigh the option of early delivery against continuing the pregnancy to support the baby's development. Choosing to continue the pregnancy for the baby's benefit is an act of generosity that is encouraged but cannot be compelled.
Ending Remarks
It's important to respect the rights to life and liberty of all people. Through our commitment to respecting those dearly held rights, our Guidelines for Reproductive Rights support both pro-life and pro-choice values. We're not just pro-choice or pro-life; we Respect People!
Thank you for reading RespectPeople.org
We appreciate your interest in ending the abortion debate respectfully. If you'd like to do more, click "Be The Change!" below. If you have evidence or valid logic that contradicts any claim on this website, we welcome corrections—just click “Send Us a Message!” to share your feedback. We'd also love to hear about what resonated with you! As always, Respect People.
Pregnant Person’s Health Crisis Abortion Exception Beginning at 23 Weeks of Gestation
Examples of medical conditions and complications that may pose serious risks to a pregnant patient's life or health include, but are not limited to: cardiovascular conditions (such as heart disease, pulmonary hypertension, and peripartum cardiomyopathy); respiratory conditions (such as lung disease and asthma); kidney or liver disease (such as acute fatty liver of pregnancy); structural abnormalities of vital organs (such as congenital or acquired abnormalities of the heart, lungs, brain, kidneys, liver, and major blood vessels); uncontrolled diabetes; cancer; autoimmune conditions; neurological conditions (including stroke); blood-clotting disorders (such as deep vein thrombosis and pulmonary embolism); hemorrhage; anemia; sickle cell disease; psychiatric conditions (including psychosis, PTSD, and major depression with suicidal ideation or risk of suicide); substance use disorders; and pregnancy-related complications, including preeclampsia/eclampsia, HELLP syndrome, chorioamnionitis, sepsis, placenta accreta, placenta previa, placental abruption, vasa previa, uterine rupture, amniotic fluid embolism, intrauterine fetal death, and retained fetal or placental tissue following pregnancy loss.
Why This Exception Exists
Pregnant people deserve the right to defend themselves against medical calamities that can arise during the course of pregnancy. Because an in-womb baby depends entirely on the pregnant person's body for its existence, the pregnant person retains the ultimate authority to decide when or whether to obtain an abortion under the framework of this exception.
Exception Eligibility
Abortion is an option when continuing a pregnancy poses a serious risk of death or substantial physical or psychiatric harm to the pregnant patient—including, but not limited to, permanent organ damage, loss of organ function, or loss of a limb—due to an underlying medical condition or a pregnancy-related medical condition or complication, including complications of labor or delivery.
Abortion being a permissible option under this exception does not automatically make it the medically preferred approach. The medically preferred approach depends on clinical judgment informed by the pregnant patient's specific medical circumstances, the comparative risks and medical appropriateness of each approach (continuing the pregnancy, labor induction, cesarean delivery, and abortion), the prospects for preserving the baby's life and health, and the prospects for preserving the pregnant patient’s life and health. Clinicians are responsible for evaluating these circumstances, explaining the available options and their risks, and making medically informed recommendations. The pregnant patient retains the ultimate authority to decide among the legally available options, and her informed preferences must be respected.
When ending the pregnancy is medically indicated for the pregnant patient and early delivery offers a medically reasonable opportunity to preserve the baby's life and health, there should be a preference for early delivery over an abortion procedure that intentionally ends the baby's life. However, this preference does not require delaying necessary care or accepting an increased risk of death or serious physical harm to the pregnant patient.
The pregnant patient need not wait until the harm is imminent or a medical emergency has developed before obtaining an abortion, because medical conditions can deteriorate in ways and on timelines that differ from conventional defensive emergencies.
When an abortion is performed after the beginning of the 23rd week of gestation with the intention of ending the life of a baby to safeguard the pregnant patient's life or health, the loss of the baby's life is a grave and tragic outcome.
Nothing in this exception is intended to restrict or discourage optimal medical treatment following pregnancy loss, such as treatment following confirmed intrauterine fetal death or the removal of retained fetal or placental tissue following miscarriage or stillbirth. Such treatment may include induction of labor, uterine evacuation, dilation and curettage (D&C), or dilation and evacuation (D&E). These procedures may be necessary to protect the pregnant patient's health and are distinct from procedures intended to end the life of a living baby.
This exception is intended not to encourage unnecessary abortion after 23 weeks while ensuring medical professionals have the clinical discretion and legal protection necessary to safeguard the pregnant patient's life and health.
Baby’s Health Crisis Abortion Exception Beginning at 23 Weeks of Gestation
Severe fetal conditions should be identified and discussed with the pregnant patient as early as reasonably possible. When a severe condition is diagnosed before the beginning of the 23rd week of gestation, decisions about whether to continue the pregnancy should ideally be made before a baby comes to exist in the fetal body.
Beginning at 23 weeks, there should be a strong moral preference for preserving the baby's life through delivery and providing appropriate medical, palliative, and/or hospice care. Depending on the baby's condition and prognosis, delivery may allow the baby to receive treatment or comfort care outside the womb.
However, this preference does not mean that abortion must be prohibited in every case involving a severe fetal condition. Some circumstances present exceptionally difficult moral dilemmas in which abortion may be morally permissible. These include circumstances in which the baby is expected to experience profound suffering that cannot be adequately relieved, as well as circumstances in which the care the baby would need exceeds what the family and available support systems can realistically provide, potentially resulting in profound suffering.
The appropriate course of action depends on the specific circumstances. Clinicians should explain the diagnosis, the degree of certainty surrounding it, the expected prognosis, and the available options. Decisions should account for the baby's likelihood of survival, the nature and duration of any expected suffering, the extent to which that suffering can be relieved, the care the baby would require, the family's capacity to provide that care, the availability of outside support, the pregnant patient's health and well-being, and the pregnant patient's informed preferences.
This exception expresses a strong moral preference for preserving the baby's life without claiming that a single rule can resolve every case. It recognizes the moral gravity of intentionally ending the baby's life while acknowledging that, in exceptional circumstances, preserving life may entail suffering or caregiving demands that create competing moral considerations. Whether abortion is morally permissible must be considered in light of the particular circumstances, rather than determined by a universal rule that treats every severe fetal diagnosis alike.
Legal Protections and Implementation
The reproductive rights outlined in this framework should be legally recognized and protected at the federal constitutional, state constitutional, federal statutory, and state statutory levels, as appropriate.
State and federal laws governing advance directives, insurance, abuse of a corpse, the handling and disposition of fetal remains, abortion, and homicide must be reviewed and, where necessary, amended to ensure that they do not interfere with the reproductive rights described in these guidelines or subject pregnant patients and medical professionals to criminal or civil liability for receiving or providing medical care consistent with these guidelines.
